The commoditisation of corporate communications
Some of the luckiest people I’ve worked with earn more than the prime minister of a medium-sized country producing communications almost nobody reads, remembers or acts upon. For years, large organisations could absorb this inefficiency because they were never really under pressure to change it. Endless slide decks, safe campaign language, committee-approved messaging and oceans of polished corporate content continued because the system rewarded activity more readily than impact. Communications functions became highly efficient production engines, but often less effective at deciding what was actually worth communicating in the first place.
Many people succeeded not because they possessed exceptional creative judgement, but because they understood how to survive within consensus-driven environments. The safest slide won. The least offensive headline survived. The idea that upset nobody became the strategy. In many corporations, the ability to navigate complexity and consensus quietly became more valuable than the ability to create something memorable. That model has worked remarkably well for a long time. GenAI is beginning to change the economics that allowed it to work.
AI changes the economics of execution
GenAI has altered the economics of creative work with remarkable speed. McKinsey estimates that generative AI could enable the automation of up to 70% of business activities across occupations, although that refers to the potential automation of activities rather than the disappearance of 70% of jobs. For communications, the more interesting question is what happens when many of the things that once required considerable time and specialist resource become much easier to produce.
A competent headline can be generated in seconds. So can a presentation structure, a social post, a campaign territory or a first visual direction. Copy can be adapted, translated and reformatted almost instantly. Images can be explored before anyone has booked a photographer or opened a design programme. The production advantage that communications functions have traditionally relied upon is becoming less scarce.
The uncomfortable reality is that execution itself is rapidly becoming commoditised. That doesn’t make good communications less important. It makes the distinction between making something and knowing what to make considerably more important.
Why judgement becomes the premium skill
As execution becomes cheaper, judgement becomes more valuable. Yet many communications environments still reward output over discernment. More campaigns. More channels. More internal content. More noise. There is often an assumption that if something has been produced, distributed and measured, it must have created value.
But audiences don’t experience communications as a production plan. They experience it as a constant stream of things competing for their attention, most of which they quite reasonably ignore.
This is where taste becomes important again. Taste is an awkward concept in corporate environments because it resists measurement. It doesn’t fit particularly neatly into dashboards, engagement metrics or quarterly reporting language. Yet the best creative leaders I’ve worked with have always possessed an unusually refined instinct for emotional timing, cultural relevance and audience psychology. They know when an idea feels alive. They know when messaging sounds frightened. They know the difference between something technically competent and something genuinely memorable. Most importantly, they know what to reject.
That becomes considerably more valuable when the cost of generating alternatives approaches zero. If everyone can produce twenty campaign concepts in thirty seconds, the valuable skill is no longer producing twenty concepts. It is understanding which one deserves attention, why it is different, what could make it better and whether it is actually worth pursuing.
The coming exposure of mediocrity
This is the part I find most interesting. AI may expose how much of communications has historically been built around production rather than judgement.
When execution becomes democratised, the sheer size of a communications function becomes less impressive. Expensive teams producing enormous quantities of competent work become easier to question when competent work can be generated almost anywhere. Safe language becomes easier to spot. Generic visual identities become easier to reproduce. Another perfectly acceptable presentation becomes harder to justify simply because it exists.
None of this means that communications professionals become redundant. Quite the opposite. It makes the genuinely useful parts of the job more visible.
Someone still has to understand the organisation, the audience and the context. Someone has to recognise when an idea is worth fighting for and when it isn’t. Someone has to notice that the technically perfect campaign has no emotional pulse, that the beautifully written message says absolutely nothing, or that the obvious answer is simply not good enough. And someone has to have the confidence to say so.
The future will not belong to the people who can produce the most content. AI will handle that effortlessly. Nor will it necessarily belong to the people who can generate the most ideas. There will be an almost limitless supply of those too. It will belong to people who can make sharper decisions in a world drowning in competent output; people with enough perspective to know what matters, enough curiosity to look beyond the obvious and enough creative instinct to recognise something worth making when they see it.
AI didn’t make creativity irrelevant. It made taste expensive again.
AI changes the economics of execution
GenAI has altered the economics of creative work almost overnight. McKinsey estimates that AI could automate up to 70% of activities associated with knowledge work, dramatically accelerating content production across industries. Suddenly the ability to generate copy, resize assets, summarise reports, localise messaging and produce competent campaign materials is no longer rare or expensive.
The uncomfortable reality for many communications teams is that execution itself is rapidly becoming commoditised. AI tools can already generate respectable headlines, social posts, presentations and visual concepts in seconds. Research into AI-assisted marketing communications consistently points toward significant gains in speed, efficiency and scale. The production advantage many organisations once relied upon is disappearing far faster than most people inside those systems realise.
But competence is not originality. And volume is not influence.
Why judgement becomes the premium skill
As execution becomes cheaper, judgement becomes dramatically more valuable. Yet many communications environments still reward output over discernment. More campaigns. More channels. More internal content. More noise. The assumption persists that visibility equals effectiveness, despite growing evidence that audiences are increasingly overwhelmed, selective and sceptical.
At the same time, people are becoming surprisingly sensitive to work that feels emotionally empty or algorithmically assembled. Research into AI-generated marketing content already highlights growing concerns around authenticity, trust and emotional credibility. Audiences may not always know why something feels generic, but they instinctively recognise when nobody with genuine perspective shaped it.
That is why taste matters again.
Taste is an awkward concept in corporate environments because it resists measurement. It cannot easily be reduced to dashboards, engagement metrics or quarterly reporting language.
Yet the best creative leaders have always possessed an unusually refined instinct for emotional timing, cultural relevance and audience psychology. They know when an idea feels alive. They know when messaging sounds frightened. They know the difference between something technically competent and something genuinely memorable.
Most importantly, they know what to reject.
The coming exposure of mediocrity
In an AI-saturated world, this becomes extraordinarily valuable. When everybody can generate twenty campaign concepts in thirty seconds, the differentiator is no longer ideation alone, but discernment. Choosing the one idea worth pursuing. Understanding human behaviour deeply enough to know what will resonate emotionally rather than simply function algorithmically.
Ironically, AI may end up exposing how little genuine creative judgement existed in some communications functions all along. Once execution becomes democratised, hierarchy becomes harder to justify. Expensive teams producing forgettable work become more visible. Safe language becomes easier to spot. Mediocrity loses its camouflage.
The future will not belong to the people who can produce the most content. AI will handle that effortlessly. It will belong to the people with perspective, curiosity, courage and creative instinct. The people capable of making sharper decisions in a world drowning in infinite mediocre output.
AI didn't make creativity irrelevant, it made taste expensive again.
Living in Basel, I tried the watch on several times, often weeks apart; sometimes in multi-brand jewellers, sometimes in the more controlled calm of the Breitling Boutique Basel itself. This matters, because it’s where the brand stops being an idea and becomes a physical environment you can inhabit for fifteen minutes.
What stood out wasn’t the theatre, because there wasn’t much of it, and that restraint felt deliberate. The lighting is flattering but not dramatic; the mirrors are placed so you catch the watch in a normal glance rather than a posed one; the language stays technical and low-ego; and the pacing is unhurried in a way that quietly signals confidence.
Even the handling feels curated: the watch is offered in a way that invites you to notice proportions and comfort first, straps appear as choices rather than upsells, and nobody behaves as though time is running out. It’s subtle, but it’s exactly the point.
Nothing revealed itself immediately, which I found oddly reassuring. I walked away more than once, unsure whether liking something quietly was reason enough to own it.